The pointless killing of Marius the giraffe

It seemed like most of the world was distraught at the pointless death of a young giraffe at a Copenhagen Zoo last Sunday.

Picture 25Marius, less than two years old and healthy, was deemed surplus to the zoos requirements. Despite several offers of a new home, zoo director Bengt Holst defended the decision to kill him, telling media that it was needed to prevent inbreeding and it is ‘a little bit like a vaccination’. Gruesomely, the zoo even dismembered Marius in front of an audience and served him up to the zoo lions afterwards.

It also came out that a safari park in the UK has recently killed 6 of its lions, including cubs, due to a rise in pregnancies. The sad and absolutely pointless death of Marius and the lions highlights the truth that zoos are not a safe haven for animals. It’s long been known that zoos regularly kill surplus animals – they use it as a management tool so that they only have the animals they want for their exhibits. According to CAPS (The Captive Animals’ Protection Society), European zoos have around 7,500 surplus animals at any one-time. In New Zealand, guidelines state that zoos are allowed to kill animals – “when births occur despite animals being on a controlled breeding programme, i.e. unwanted pregnancies” or “when there is over-representation of a particular sex or genetic line”. In 2009 Zion Wildlife Park was accused by former workers of killing cubs by bashing them on the head with rocks.


Conservation lies

We’re often told that zoos are essential for conservation but despite claims to the contrary, most zoo conservation programmes have poor results for the individual animals, and rarely reintroduce the animals to the wild. Most animal species in zoos are not endangered (the sub species of giraffe that Marius was from are not under threat) so are merely kept for public entertainment.

Even for those that are endangered, returning captive-bred animals to the wild is difficult, inefficient and costly and most zoos don’t even attempt it. The only true way we’ll help prevent extinction is in situ habitat protection.zoos_FB1

We have to ask then, why are they here? It certainly serves little educational purpose. Animals in zoos suffer from excruciating boredom, social frustration and loneliness, which can lead to stress-induced zoochosis. Studying them in captivity gives us a skewed picture of their true behaviour and visitors leave without having learned anything significant – there is nothing inspiring about seeing depressed animals.

Zoos profit financially from showing baby animals. When they grow up they are not so interesting anymore. I think the Conservationist Damian Aspinall (and zoo owner who has seen the light) said it best “Zoos say they are in the business of conservation. In my opinion, that’s a lie. They are in the conservation of business.”

Mandy Carter, Campaign Manager


4 Comments Add yours

  1. Rachel Major says:

    I was gutted when I heard this I cried and cried.Poor baby they should have been looking after him. but they killed him and made his death a spectacle.They cut him up in front of children and fed him to the lions what sort of message dose that send to children It made him seem worthless. There had even been offers to re-home him.
    The evil man ( his name is Holst) said he would do it again if he thought fit.I wish that the word had got round before this happened and maybe it could have been stopped

  2. danna says:

    what we need to do is boycott the companies that fund these zoos.

  3. Carol says:

    If natural habitat is being destroyed then zoo bred animals can never be returned to the wild. I don’t know of any zoo involved in serious habitat conservation, so it’s time they admitted that this business is about entertainment and nothing really to do with conservation. Why are they so concerned with protecting gene pools when there is no future for the animals except behind bars?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s